How to Choose the Right LinkedIn Marketing Agency

In today’s B2B landscape, LinkedIn stands as the premier platform for professionals to make meaningful connections and drive real business growth. But with countless agencies claiming expertise in LinkedIn marketing, how do you find the right partner?

Choosing a LinkedIn marketing agency is a big decision. It impacts your brand’s presence, lead quality, and bottom line. Here’s a comprehensive guide to help you find a LinkedIn marketing partner who truly understands how to unlock the platform’s potential for your business.

Why LinkedIn Marketing?

Before diving into the selection process, it’s essential to understand LinkedIn’s unique position. LinkedIn isn’t just a job search platform; it’s a powerful tool for building relationships, establishing thought leadership, and driving B2B sales. Here are some compelling statistics:

• LinkedIn has over 1 billion members, with 4 out of 5 decision-makers active on the platform.
• LinkedIn content is trusted twice as much as content on other social media channels.
• The platform consistently delivers high-quality leads with a clear intent to engage and invest.
• 38% of B2B Marketers say LinkedIn has generated revenue for them (3x the next best social media site)

However, tapping into LinkedIn’s potential requires more than just posting content or running ads. You need a strategic approach tailored to LinkedIn’s algorithms, user behaviour, and business dynamics—this is where a specialised agency comes in.

3 Characteristics that Make a Great LinkedIn Marketing Agency

When evaluating LinkedIn marketing agencies, focus on these three essential traits:

1. LinkedIn-Specific Expertise

LinkedIn is a unique platform with its own set of best practices, algorithms, and user behaviours. The agency you choose should have in-depth knowledge and experience specifically with LinkedIn marketing. A generalist social media agency may not fully understand the nuances of LinkedIn, such as B2B lead targeting, LinkedIn’s algorithm, or social selling techniques.

What to look for:

• Evidence of LinkedIn-specific campaigns.
• A deep understanding of LinkedIn’s targeting options and features.
• Case studies that showcase LinkedIn as a primary platform.
• Experience educating people on how to use LinkedIn both inperson and online
• Look at their LinkedIn profile – are they practising what they preach?

2. Focus on ROI and Lead Quality

LinkedIn marketing is about generating leads, but not just any leads—high-quality, intent-driven leads. A great LinkedIn marketing agency will prioritise lead quality over volume, focusing on connecting you with the right decision-makers who are more likely to convert.

What to look for:

• Metrics that directly link to ROI eg. lead quantity & quality
• A track record of helping clients achieve high ROI through LinkedIn campaigns.
• A focus on sustainable growth, not just vanity metrics like likes and impressions.
• Testimonials on LinkedIn from previous clients sharing their results
• Awards or industry recognitions for their LinkedIn campaigns

3. Commitment to Building Relationships

LinkedIn isn’t just a place to push ads; it’s a platform for building relationships. A successful LinkedIn marketing agency should prioritise relationship-building, content creation, and engagement strategies that establish trust and authority.

What to look for:

• An emphasis on social selling and relationship-based marketing.
• Expertise in creating thought leadership content.
• A willingness to guide you on engaging with leads and nurturing connections over time.
• Positive customer feedback on their LinkedIn profile, on their content and on Google

Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing a LinkedIn Marketing Agency

Selecting the wrong LinkedIn marketing agency can do more harm than good. Here are some common mistakes to avoid and the potential consequences:

1. Choosing an Agency Without LinkedIn Expertise

LinkedIn marketing requires a specialised skill set. If you hire an agency that lacks in-depth knowledge of LinkedIn, you risk wasting time and resources on strategies that don’t work. General social media tactics don’t always translate well to LinkedIn’s professional audience, and this can result in low engagement and poor ROI.

Risk: No meaningful results, wasted time, and minimal impact on lead generation.

2. Falling for “Growth Hacks” and Automation Promises

LinkedIn has strict guidelines against aggressive automation and spammy tactics. Some agencies promise rapid results through dodgy automated tools or “growth hacks” that violate LinkedIn’s policies. While these methods may produce short-term spikes, they put your account at risk of being flagged or even permanently banned by LinkedIn.

Risk: Account suspension or ban, damaging your brand’s reputation and wasting your investment.

3. Prioritising Lead Volume Over Lead Quality

An agency that boasts about generating hundreds of leads without considering quality might not have your best interests in mind. On LinkedIn, it’s not about quantity; it’s about connecting with prospects who are genuinely interested and likely to convert. Focusing only on lead volume can flood your sales pipeline with unqualified leads, which wastes your team’s time and resources.

Risk: High volume of unqualified leads, wasted sales efforts, and a lower return on investment.

4. Hiring an Agency That Delegates Work to Junior Staff

Some agencies delegate your strategy to junior staff or third-party teams, resulting in inconsistent messaging and less strategic oversight. LinkedIn marketing requires a level of expertise and precision that can only come from experienced professionals. If your campaign is being handled by inexperienced staff, you may not see the results you’re hoping for.

Risk: Poorly executed strategy, lack of accountability, and diminished results.

5. Overlooking the Importance of Relationship-Building

LinkedIn is about building long-term, trust-based relationships. An agency that treats LinkedIn like any other ad platform may focus too heavily on direct sales and overlook the value of relationship-building. This approach can alienate potential clients and miss out on the platform’s true potential for B2B growth.

Risk: Lost opportunities to build trust, damaged brand reputation, and low engagement.

How to Work with a LinkedIn Marketing Agency

Once you’ve selected an agency, it’s essential to set the foundation for a productive partnership. Here’s how to ensure smooth collaboration:

1. Define Clear Goals and Expectations

LinkedIn marketing can serve a variety of business objectives – lead generation, brand awareness, thought leadership, or networking. Make sure both you and the agency are aligned on specific goals from the start. Clearly communicate your priorities, target audience, and expectations for outcomes.

2. Establish Regular Communication

Effective communication is key to a successful agency partnership. Set up regular check-ins to discuss progress, review metrics, and refine strategies. Weekly or bi-weekly meetings allow both parties to stay aligned and make adjustments as needed.

3. Understand Their Process and Your Role

Every LinkedIn marketing agency has its own approach. Some agencies handle everything from strategy to execution, while others may expect more involvement from you or your team. Make sure you understand what the agency will manage and what they need from you, such as approvals, content inputs, or direct engagement with leads.

How to Find the Right LinkedIn Marketing Agency for You

Selecting the best LinkedIn marketing agency goes beyond just ticking boxes. Here are practical steps to find the agency that’s the right fit for your business:

1. Ask for LinkedIn-Specific Case Studies

Case studies provide insight into the agency’s experience with LinkedIn. Ask for examples of clients they’ve helped on LinkedIn, focusing on lead generation, profile optimisation, or content marketing. Look for results that align with your goals, like number of leads, lead conversion rates, revenue generated, engagement metrics, or ROI.

2. Review Client Testimonials and Social Proof

A reputable LinkedIn marketing agency should have testimonials and references from previous clients. Look for feedback that mentions professionalism, communication, and measurable results. Client testimonials can give you confidence in the agency’s ability to deliver on their promises.

If they’re good at what they do they should be a sought after trainer and speaker, as well as actively managing campaigns across multiple industries. If you’re based in Melbourne for example, see what other businesses have done the same LinkedIn training in Melbourne and what their feedback was.

3. Evaluate Their Thought Leadership

An experienced LinkedIn agency should demonstrate their expertise by producing high-quality content themselves. Check if the agency has published articles, guides, or case studies about LinkedIn strategies. Their thought leadership content can reveal their approach, values, and commitment to helping clients succeed on LinkedIn.

If they’re good at what they do, they should be sought-after for LinkedIn training and LinkedIn speaking engagements. You can check their track record by doing a quick Google or YouTube search.

4. Ask These Critical Questions

To make an informed decision, ask prospective agencies these questions:

• Can you show LinkedIn-specific case studies and results?
• How many LinkedIn marketing campaigns have you managed?
• Who are some of the clients you have worked with in the past?
• Where can I find examples of you sharing your LinkedIn marketing expertise?
• Have you won any awards for your LinkedIn marketing campaigns?
• How do you measure LinkedIn campaign performance?
• Who will manage my account, and what experience do they have with LinkedIn?
• What kind of ongoing support do you offer after launching a campaign?

Why Bibby Media Group is a Trusted Choice for LinkedIn Marketing

At Bibby Media Group, we’re not just another LinkedIn marketing agency—we’re pioneers in the industry. Founded by Nathanial Bibby, Australia’s first LinkedIn marketing specialist, we’ve been setting the standard for LinkedIn success for over a decade.

What sets us apart?

• Award-Winning Expertise: Nathanial Bibby has been recognised as the #1 LinkedIn Expert in the Asia-Pacific by the Social Media Marketing Institute. We’ve won Best Use of LinkedIn twice (2019 and 2020) and have been finalists for several other industry awards.
• Proven Results: We’ve generated over $500 million in sales for clients and consistently deliver 20-150 qualified leads per month. Our results go beyond vanity metrics, providing meaningful connections and measurable growth for our clients.
• Client Trust and Social Proof: With over 118 LinkedIn recommendations from clients and 36 glowing Google reviews, we’re proud of the trust we’ve earned. Nathanial’s content on LinkedIn has reached over 20 million views, demonstrating our ability to create impactful content that resonates with LinkedIn audiences.
• Trusted by Leading Brands: We’ve worked with some of the world’s most respected brands, including Apple, Westpac, Channel 7, Hubspot, Capital Group, Linktree, and Western Union. Our clients range from industry giants to ambitious small businesses, all seeking growth and authority on LinkedIn.
• End-to-End LinkedIn Solutions: We’re a full-service LinkedIn marketing agency, handling everything from profile optimisation, lead generation, content creation, and LinkedIn ads. Our comprehensive approach lets you focus on your business while we drive the results that matter.

When you work with us, you’ll work directly with Nathanial Bibby. Unlike other agencies, we don’t delegate your strategy to junior staff. Nathanial personally oversees every campaign, ensuring the highest standards and maximising your ROI.

Conclusion

With more professionals and decision-makers using LinkedIn to research brands and make purchasing decisions, it’s never been a better time to leverage LinkedIn as a marketing powerhouse. The potential is immense, but LinkedIn success requires more than just posting updates—it demands a strategic, targeted approach.

If you’re ready to take LinkedIn seriously but feel like you’re missing the expertise or resources, partnering with a LinkedIn marketing agency is the next logical step.

The first step in choosing the right agency is to get clear on your goals. Are you aiming for lead generation, brand authority, or relationship-building? Knowing exactly what you want will help you find a LinkedIn partner with the right expertise to make those outcomes a reality.

If you’re ready to harness LinkedIn as a driver for growth, we’d love to help. Get in touch to discuss your goals, and let’s see if Bibby Media Group is the right fit to take your LinkedIn strategy to the next level.

Frequently Asked Questions

Get Your LinkedIn Marketing Strategy Right with The LinkedIn Content Planner!

Free download available for a limited time, annual planner for your LinkedIn marketing – CLICK HERE.